Thursday, 18 July 2013

HIV Related News Coverage


Before taking this course on HIV in South Africa, I really did not know much about HIV and the history behind it. However, with the course drawing to an end, I look back and realize how much I have learned in such a small amount of time. I am much more informed about the virus, and feel more drawn to delving into news stories related to HIV.
HIV Structure
In particular, a recent news story that was widely publicized and caught my attention involves the two patients from Boston’s Brigham and Women’s Hospital who were both HIV-positive for thirty years and received bone marrow stem cell transplants to treat their lymphoma. After the bone marrow transplants, one patient has not had detectible HIV for two years, and the other for four years. Recently both patients have stopped taking ART, and as of now, have been HIV-free. Specifically, one has not been taking ART for fifteen weeks and the other for seven weeks. This is not the first time that stories like these have happened; in a similar light the “Berlin Patient,” Timothy Brown, was “…the first person to be cured of HIV after receiving a bone marrow transplant for leukemia in 2007.” However, there is a key difference between the Boston patients and Mr. Brown. Unlike the Berlin Patient, they did not receive stem cells with the rare genetic mutation, CCR5, which makes a person “…virtually resistant to HIV.” Instead, according to Donald G. McNeil of The New York Times, the Boston patients’ transplanted cells attacked their chemotherapy-weekend bone marrow cells, suggesting that the rare gene is not necessary to potentially eradicate HIV.  
Researcher working on stem cell transplants
 News like this is exciting because it adds to the number of patients who are potentially cured from HIV and opens up another avenue for research on HIV treatment. However, Dr. Henrich stated at an AIDS Society Conference in Kuala Lumpur that, “it is too early to say for sure that the virus has disappeared from their bodies altogether.” Bone marrow is a major area for HIV to be found, and the transplant most likely “…attacked the remaining bone marrow, which was harboring the virus,” but the article elaborated that HIV can be “hiding” in the gastrointestinal track or brain tissue.
So, what does all this implicate for the months ahead? First off, if the virus resurfaces, then the brain tissue and gastrointestinal track could also be areas where the virus can be found and that, “…new approaches to measuring the reservoir at relevant sites will be needed to guide the development of HIV curative strategies.” If this occurs, perhaps future research for HIV may focus on detecting sites where the virus can be found and more ways to identify the virus sooner. Secondly, it was also mentioned by Dr. Henrich that, “We have not demonstrated cure, we’re going to need longer follow-up. What we can say is if the virus does stay away for a year or even two years after we stopped the treatment, that the chances of the virus rebounding are going to be extremely low.” If this scenario occurs, what will be the cut-off time to declaring that patients are HIV-free? Also, can there ever be a set, uniform standard where patients can be deemed HIV-free, or will there always be an uncertainty that the virus can come back? Lastly, even if the Boston patients are found to still remain void of the virus after two years, I do not think that their treatments will be applicable for the population at large. Because stem cell therapy is so expensive, its practicality to be used worldwide for the 34 million infected is slim. But regardless of practicality, their transplants can have future implications on researching gene therapy as a possible cure for HIV.

In the months ahead, I am excited to see how much of an impact these two patients will have on the future of HIV research, prevention, and treatment and hear about the discoveries from this treatment over the long run.

-Ilana Regenbogen

*Information was gathered from the following resources:
1. “Bone marrow stem-cell therapy appears to have eradicated HIV in two patients.” 4/7/2013. <http://www.abc.net.au/news/2013-07-04/stem-cell-therapy-wipes-out-hiv-in-two-patients/4798396>.
2. Gallagher, James. “Bone marrow ‘frees men of HIV drugs.’” <http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-23132561>.
3. Images can be found in Google. 

Wednesday, 17 July 2013

The Ironic South African Neighbors - Malnutrition and Obesity


I never anticipated finding any degree of economic diversity within the black townships in Cape Town. I had always imagined that life in the township fell under a single economic classification. That being said, after spending a substantial amount of time in two black townships on the outskirts of Cape Town, Philippi and Langa, I began to realize that these initial assumptions were far from the truth.

These evident economic discrepancies first came to my attention when I observed vast differences in the daily diet consumed by individuals within the townships. 
           
Philippi and Langa look very similar. Both townships have broken streets lined with temporary housing, spaza shops, barbers, and fruit stands. In general, they “felt” very comparable. 

Langa
Philippi

Initially, I just assumed almost everyone was “poor” in black townships. And in my mind, it followed that everyone must be hungry. At the time when this was my central belief, I had been volunteering in Philipi with an organization called Ons Plek for about three weeks. This program in Philippi models an after-school daycare/tutoring program, with the primary intention of keeping at-risk youth off of the streets and in school. The program accepts children whose parents are financially strained, sick, or otherwise excusably preoccupied.

Everyday, when the students come to the program, they are given with two sandwiches – one butter sandwich, and one jam sandwich. (right)

As soon as the students are called to eat, they run at full speed towards the corrugated steel shack where the sandwiches have been prepared. The food is then consumed faster than it was distributed. It is so evident that these kids are always hungry. I am told that for some of these children, the food distributed at the program is their only meal of the day. This meal has little to no nutritional value. I would argue that if food were not provided for the children at this program, no children would attend.

My experience with the children in Philippi undoubtedly worked to form my initial assumptions surrounding life in the township. However, I soon found that my initial assumptions pertaining to life in the township were far from the overarching reality. In other words, living in the township does not imply that families cannot afford to put food on the table.



My Home-Stay "Mom" and I
This became clear during my home-stay in Langa. I stayed in a small home: two-bedrooms, one bathroom, a small kitchen, and a small living room. I would say it was an average size home compared to the rest that I saw in Langa. During my stay at this home, I was offered at least FIVE meals a day. If I didn’t eat all of my food my host mother would ask me why, and regardless of my answer, she would then tell me to eat more. I was actually in physical pain by the end of my stay in Langa. One morning, I woke up and went to the neighbor’s house. When I walked in, I was offered an enormous slice of cake . . . at 10am. In no way, were these people starving. That is for certain. In fact, it was visibly evident that a large portion of this community was overeating, leading to problems with obesity.


This story just serves to highlight two main points:

1.)   There is a great degree of economic diversity within the township. In other words there is a significant financial range within the lower economic class.
2.)   Both malnutrition and obesity are huge problems within these townships. It is very ironic how both of these issues present themselves within similar demographics. It would be interesting to further investigate the reasons behind this reality.

-Alison Burklund


Tuesday, 16 July 2013

                As all of us here in Cape Town have been placed at different non-governmental organizations (NGOs), Lindsay, Sierra, Shelby, and I (Brett) currently work at an organization called Yabonga. This organization started out as a sort of daycare for women taking care of young children. As HIV took hold in South Africa however, Yabonga evolved to become an organization that provides support to children whose lives have been affected by HIV. This does not necessarily mean that each child in Yabonga is currently living with HIV; the child could have a close family member who is infected or have lost a parent to HIV, just as long as HIV has affected the child’s life in some way. Yabonga provides many services to these children such as support for dealing with HIV, teaching them useful skills such as baking and gardening, and helping them with school work and the college application process. During our time at Yabonga, we were put in charge of planning a career guidance workshop for kids from grades 10-12. The workshop would take place at Yabonga’s new youth center in one of Cape Town’s many townships, Khayelitsha. The center itself was much nicer than the buildings around it, but small by American standards. It consisted of a kitchen, restroom, storage room, break room, and a larger, open room for conducting activities. In the back of the main building, there was a red shack that we learned would be used as a computer lab for the students. Next to the two buildings was an open field for outdoor sports such as soccer.
The Yabonga main office

                During our second week of working at Yabonga, we attended the opening of said youth center, an event that resembled that of a party or celebration much more than a formal ceremony. There was singing, dancing, skits, and speeches. Students, parents, and faculty from support centers from all over the Cape Town area came to the youth center at the opening, completely filling it. After several of Yabonga’s managers and teachers gave speeches about the youth center (some in Xhosa, one of South Africa’s many native languages), the students put on performances for the crowd gathered there. All four of us American students were shocked by the amazingly high quality of each and every performance. The skits and songs were heartfelt and full of emotion, while the dances were choreographed to a degree of quality we did not expect from high school students. Even the audience became incredibly animated and cheered loudly as the students performed. Perhaps one of the most striking performances was put on by an all-male group that talked about some of their own experiences through song. One of the boys announced to the audience that when he disclosed his HIV positive status to his parents, he was immediately kicked out of the house. The disgust felt by the members of the audience was immediately seen and heard as they shouted their disagreement with the boy’s parents.
Opening of the youth center

                Also interesting to us was how much of a role music and dance played in the community’s actions throughout the entire occasion. There would be points where one woman would sing three notes and, like a well-trained chorus, the rest of the audience would rise up in song and dance. At the end of the youth center opening, music was played and everybody, young and old, started dancing.
                At the end of the day, our experience at the youth center was perhaps one of our most intimate looks into the culture of South Africa’s townships. The people we met and activities we observed gave a small look into just how jubilant and joyful the Yabonga community can be.

-Brett Will

Sunday, 14 July 2013

Working at Sonke Gender Justice Network

  Every Monday, Wednesday, and Friday for the 6 weeks that we are in Cape Town, Anita, Maggie, and I have made the trek to the UCT Upper Campus, climbed aboard the bright blue Jammie Shuttle, and walked from UCT’s Hiddingh campus to our placement site in the heart of downtown Cape Town. Our office is located in a beautiful building surrounded by restaurants, shops, and craft vendors right by St. George’s Mall and Greenmarket Square. My community based organization is Sonke Gender Justice Network. Sonke is a non-profit organization based in South Africa that aims to reduce the spread of HIV, promote gender equality and the changing of traditional gender roles, and reduce domestic and gender-based violence. It does so by encouraging the government, the community, and individual citizens to support men and boys in taking action. Sonke aims to effect change in South Africa and internationally by addressing government policies, traditional cultures, societal organizations, the media, and the family, which influence both community norms and practices and individual attitudes.
Anita and I in the intern office
   I am an intern in the Monitoring & Evaluation department, which monitors the implementation of Sonke’s many programs and initiatives, conducts operational research, and evaluates the impact of the programs. My work has largely been centered on the creation of a visual behavior change model to be displayed in the offices of the organization, as well as an accompanying report. The presence of a visual model will hopefully strengthen Sonke’s process of developing, implementing, and evaluating behavior change communication programs by providing information about the current theories of how behavior change occurs. With the visual model, people will thus hopefully better understand the psychological factors that go into individual and collective behavior change decisions, as well as the roles that skills & knowledge and environmental context play.
Anita, Maggie, and I at the Sonke Prison Youth Day Event

   One of Sonke’s organizational goals is the transformation of unequal power between men and women to create an environment with gender equality and diminished vulnerability of men and women to problems like gender-based violence and HIV. Approaches that are traditionally health-based are inadequate and need to include the social, cultural, economic, and human rights aspects. Effective responses address everyone affected by the issue in a human rights framework that directly attacks inequality. With gender equality in both sexual relationships and social relationships, the occurrence of gender-based violence and HIV can be reduced. Gender equality can be achieved by challenging traditional notions of masculinity found in South Africa and all over the world to create a culture where men and boys see females as equals in all contexts. The social construction of masculinity often condones male dominance over women and leads to violence against women and girls. Sonke recognizes that simply empowering women is not enough to create an equal power relationship between men and women, but rather men and boys need to change their behavior as well.
Sonke's One Man Can campaign
  In addition, addressing notions of masculinity as a behavior change can encourage males to reduce other health-destructive behaviors like risky sexual behavior, alcohol abuse, and failure to seek medical care. Thus while gender equality is part of Sonke’s vision and a goal of its work, direct application of the goal to behavior change theory can be achieved through changing men and boys’ notions of masculinity. Interventions based on this behavior change theory can be effective if organizations like Sonke and the individual and community challenge and change negative constructions of masculinity. This behavior change is what leads to improved health, directly observed in a reduction of the number of men and women suffering from gender-based violence and HIV.
  So far, I have completed the model and report, which my supervisor says she wants me to present at the next internal staff training. This is very exciting but a bit nerve-wracking! My next project will be assisting with operational research on Sonke’s MenEngage Africa program by interviewing their regional partners about the successes and challenges of the MenEngage program so far. That information will be used to make changes before the next phase of the program begins.
  It has been a great experience working at Sonke with my fellow interns Anita and Maggie, and the incredible Sonke staff. I will miss stopping at Motherland Coffee Company in the morning when we arrive at work before the doors are unlocked, occasionally dashing down to Crush or the Food Lover’s Market for lunch, and climbing up and down the many flights of stairs to meet with our supervisors or attend staff meetings. We only have one week left at our placement sites and in Cape Town, and it will definitely be sad to leave.


Written by Jill Anderson

Marketing Medicines: An Introduction to AIDS Denialism and Traditional Healing


With the election of Thabo Mbeki, 1999 marked the beginning of an era of government-endorsed AIDS denialism. This ideological view denies the link between the human immunodeficiency virus and acquired immune deficiency syndrome. Given the political history of Apartheid and its mark on South African society, it is not difficult to see how former president Thabo Mbeki and his Minister of Health, Manto Tshabalala-Msimang, exerted political power over South Africans and corrupted ARV distribution efforts of organizations like the TAC. The more important question was why they took such measures regardless of local, national, and international pressure to acknowledge widely accepted information regarding HIV, AIDS, and ARV treatment.

Courtesy of popular South African cartoonist,
Jonathan Shapiro 
In South Africa, denialism centered around fear of a global pharmaceutical conspiracy, critique of African sexuality, promotion of indigenous solutions, such as Virodene, and poverty as the key determinant of the epidemic. Mbeki’s reasons, though falsifiable, are plausible if perceived through the eyes of a leader of a country with a history of mistrust and of a continued movement to reclaim pride in the South African nation and its sacrosanct traditions. Regardless of Mbeki’s motivations, the former president’s ideological and political beliefs concerning the HIV epidemic dictated the course of treatment for millions of people in South Africa. 
           
Established in 1965, The Medicines and Related Substances Control Act was the principal piece of legislation governing the regulation and distribution of medicines in South Africa. While the act prohibited the sale of “medicines subject to registration unless registered,” the registration of medicines was left to the Medicines Control Council, whose integrity was compromised after leaders had been dismissed after disagreeing with Mbeki’s stance on Virodene and other African “medicines.” As a result, medicines were not effectively regulated and quackery ran rampant throughout South Africa.

            
The average price of olive oil is R 62.68
A loaf of white bread costs  R 9.2
Traditional HIV medicines endorsed by the South African government during the AIDS denialism era included beetroot, garlic, lemon, olive oil, and the African potato. These medicines were promoted by Tshabalala-Msimang in addition to good general health and nutrition. This stance on HIV treatment presented problems for public health workers. While all of the expensive ”cures” recommended by Tshabalala-Msimang ranged from being ineffective to harmful for patients with HIV and AIDS, nutrition was and will always be an important aspect of health. The topic of nutrition is one of many overlapping premises of western and traditional health, but I was ignorant of this strange relationship until the about halfway through our time abroad. 

            
The past few weeks, the other interns at Sonke and I have occasionally ordered take-away lunches at a fresh food café on St. George’s Mall in Cape Town, called “Crush.” Upon first entering the café, Jill commented that she felt like she was back in the States at a west coast bistro and Anita affirmed that the shop would get a lot of business if it were on the Hopkins campus. As we sat waiting for our mozzarella and tomato sandwiches I took a closer look at the menu board. The types of food sold in the store were marketed much like the traditional remedies on flyers circulating around the city and throughout the townships, with suggestive menu items that “boost your health” including “immune-boosting juices” like the Revitaliser, Pear & Ginger Cleanser, and wheatgrass shots. Interestingly enough, expensive bottles of olive oil were displayed strategically next to the cash register and Hippocrates' quote “Let food be your medicine and medicine be your food” was written in large orange bubble letters across the right side of the menu board. I began to laugh, thinking “wow, Dr. Manto would have loved this place!” Confusion quickly overtook any humor in the situation. How could clever advertising schemes and homeopathic mumbo jumbo appeal to both AIDS denialists and western-educated Hopkins students? What is it about traditional medicine that appeals to everyone around the world, regardless of cultural or educational background?

Crush Menu Board
I have come to the conclusion that there are no simple answers to these questions. Anyone who tries to tell you otherwise is just as guilty of peddling misinformation as quacks selling bogus HIV treatments. I have, however, identified a few aspects of traditional medicine that are attractive to me as an American student of healthcare policy and management. First and foremost, traditional medicine is often more accessible to South Africans. This is largely because of the long queues at local clinics, the cost of traveling to the clinics and missing work, and the mistrust of the public healthcare system.  Traditional healers are known for being great listeners and generally spend quite a bit of time talking with their patients. This fosters powerful, trusting relationships that appeal to patients at the most basic human level. Healers also take a more holistic approach to healing. They view the body not just as a conglomeration of medical problems and machinery, but as an individual being with physical and spiritual needs.

If I am not mistaken, these are aspects of healthcare that patients report are lacking in most hospitals stateside. Like it or not, traditional medicine has its place in health systems around the world, regardless of the physical evidence (or in some cases lack thereof) supporting its effectiveness. Until evidence-based medicine is made accessible and affordable, traditional remedies will continue to be the first line of defense for many populations around the world. 


Written by Maggie Storm